TÜRKÇE
18.05.2012
29.01.2011 15:41


Assoc. Prof. Ahmet UYSAL

auysal@sde.org.tr
CV

A Democratic Egypt Will Benefit All

 

There is a wide-spread misconception that Muslim societies cannot sustain a democratic system. However, the Muslim societies did not have a chance to choose the type of government they live under let alone to draw the borders of their states. The Middle Eastern order is based on the Sykes-Picot agreement signed between Britain and France after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. It was an unnatural order not regarding social, ethnic and religious characteristics of the region. This order was maintained even after Arab societies gained their independence after the World War II. Probably due to the heat of polarization during the Cold War era, these societies were not given a chance for democracy.
 
Even the collapse of the Berlin Wall and the end of Cold War era did not change the situation. After the democratic transition of the Eastern Europe, it was the Arabs’ turn to live under democratic regimes. It did not happen not because the region populated by mostly Muslim Arabs do not need or want democracy but it was delayed due to the strategic importance of the authoritarian Arab world for the energy sources and for the security of Israel, a western implant in the region.
 
The US leaders realized the unsustainable nature of the situation in the Middle East and the need for a democratic reform. George W. Bush’s Neo-Conservative plans to democratize the region was a false start. It was because the US envisaged exporting democracy selectively (i.e. according to their relative interests) and by force rather than supporting democratic movements’ demands in every country. Moreover, the nationalist and unilateral approach of the Neo-conservatives was not resonant with the local demands for democracy, accountability and the rule of law. The US seemed to want democracy for the challenger’s of US hegemony or the so-called axis of evil while ignoring the demands for democratization in the US allies such as Egypt and Jordan.
 
Like others, Egyptian people have demanded democratization for a long time but they were brutally suppressed. In 2008 Muhammed Al-Baradai, the former head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, came to Egypt to promote reform in Egypt. He demanded a democratic constitution, fair-elections and social reforms in Egypt. However, the government showed a deaf ear to these demands. Even though he was well known in the West, the US and European leaders did not support his calls for reform. The US continued to support the Egyptian regime financially and with arms and did not want to risk any change, worrying it might end-up in the Brotherhood hands.
 
Yesterday Obama said he told Mubarak to reform Egyptian system. Even though it is a positive step and must be welcomed, it also shows they hold the strings and are also responsible a long delay in that regard. It is probably too little, too late as the protestors want a change in the regime long ruled by former generals. Those who are responsible for corrupting the system can hardly reform it. Husni Mubarak’s promised democratic reforms on Friday night will probably materialize after his departure.
 
Democratic reforms and good governance will bring Egypt from poverty and underdevelopment, clearly benefiting the Egyptian people with its Muslims and Christians. As the largest and central country of the Middle East, Egypt’s social and economic development will decrease radical and anti-western tendencies among Arabs. A democratic Egypt can be a hub for stability in the region to prevent or alleviate the social, cultural and political upheavals like the ones we currently witness in Lebanon, Sudan and Yemen. By consolidating its domestic welfare and achieving stability, trough democracy, Turkey contributes to the stability in Iraq and Lebanon. Similarly, a democratic Egypt can do more of that as a central Arab country. Availability of democratic means for expression grievances can limit the tendency for radicalism and terrorism in the world. This will even help Israel if it wants dialogue, a fair peace and justice in the Middle East.
 
In brief, Egyptian democracy can help bring development and stability to the region. Since almost every one in the world is concerned with the stability in the region, these new developments will benefit all; well, almost all.

 

 


OTHER ARTICLES OF THE AUTHOR
Arab Spring and Erdogan’s Visit to Egypt - 14 Eylül 2011 Çarşamba 10:54
Fine Tuning Civil-Military relations in Turkey - 15 Ağustos 2011 Pazartesi 16:09
Syria’s Bloody Distraction Tactics and Turkey - 11 Ağustos 2011 Perşembe 12:58
Erdogan’s Victory and the Middle East - 13 Haziran 2011 Pazartesi 15:36
Reform of Authoritarian Regimes in the Middle East? - 02 Mayıs 2011 Pazartesi 15:55
Russia, China, Turkey and India on the Egyptian Revolution - 27 Şubat 2011 Pazar 23:07
The Turkish Model for the New West-Arab Relations - 10 Şubat 2011 Perşembe 17:59
A Democratic Egypt Will Benefit All - 29 Ocak 2011 Cumartesi 15:41
Constitutional Amendment in Turkey a Major Step Forward - 12 Temmuz 2010 Pazartesi 14:26
Turkey, Israel & the USA While the Opportunities Slipping Away - 21 Haziran 2010 Pazartesi 12:29
Israel’s Major Miscalculations - 03 Haziran 2010 Perşembe 10:53
Mr. Kılıçdaroğlu and the Foreign Policy - 27 Mayıs 2010 Perşembe 09:31
The Value of New Turkish Foreign Policy for the World Peace - 24 Mart 2010 Çarşamba 12:12


IST will be holding a conference titled “Transatlantic Relations in the Framework of Actual Political Developments” at 10 am (10.00) on April 12th 2012.
09.04.2012 16:34:39

IST will be holding a conference titled "Global Financial Crisis and its Reflections on Turkey" at 3 pm (15:00) on February 10th, 2012 with the participation of Deputy Prime Minister Ali Babacan...
08.02.2012 17:34:41

SDE-Era Econometrics Seminar Series : "THE IMPACT OF OIL PRICE SHOCKS ON THE ECONOMIC GROWTH OF SELECTED MENA COUNTRIES
21.10.2011 13:55:20

SDE holds a panel on "International Arbitration Tribune and Turkey"
20.09.2011 13:57:47


<Mayıs 2012>
PtSaÇaPeCuCtPz
30123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031123
45678910

Do you favor Turkey's suspension of diplomatic relations with Israel?

Yes
No
No Idea


Content of this site is copyrighted to SDE. Except reasonable and partial quotation and exploitation under the Act No. 5846, Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works, via proper citation, may not be used or re-published without prior permission by SDE. Except for the institutional information on SDE, and the studies of SDE Academic Staff; all opinions and assessments expressed in this site reflect only the opinions of their authors and do not represent the institutional opinion of SDE.
Portal Design and Development: Omedya