TÜRKÇE
18.05.2012
11.03.2010 14:49


Prof. Dr. Yasin Aktay
SDE Director
yaktay@sde.org.tr
CV

The Economic and Political Aspects of the Genocide Discourse

When the vote by a Congressional Committee in Washington on the Armenian resolution was 23 to 22, the Turkish public reacted to this resolution. Therefore, the reaction of the Turkish public shows that it is possible to have commonality in reaction although it is impossible to reach an agreement in politics. Thus, regardless of the heated debates and hardships in politics due to tensions, new problems make us to be aware of what is going on. However, how long it will keep us awake is another issue. Moreover, what is more important is whether we take the news as good news in order to defeat our enemies or with a deep sorrow.

Indeed, the Armenian issue is complicated. Even if we need to confront history, it is awkward and useless for the USA whose history is full of various massacres and wars, to remind us this issue. But, no one really feels the pains of Armenians and human beings of a hundred year ago. It is a right to expect the ones who are ready to feel the pains of Armenians and announce this to the world, similarly to be sensitive to the events happening just around them. If they are sensitive because they do not want the situations get worse, their attitudes may be respectable. But, if it is so, these attitudes are supposed to end today’s cruelty.

This mentality should definitely be handled cautiously. A justice claim for the past events by no means can be hold responsible for today’s cruelty. However, if these countries are the USA, France, and Holland, the attempts of these countries to question Turkey’s history, in the strictest sense of the word, is awkward.

The determination of historical event with a parliamentary resolution is an illustration of the essence of history. History is never an objective reflection of past events. If a historical event does not interest us today, it is not even history for us. And when we are interested in a historical event, it means we do not understand the true essence of the event but our perspective is what matters. If there is objective history in real sense, it must be possible as long as we are “disinterested”. However, “interest” is a key word and it is more related to “interest, profit” than objectivity.

That is why we do have neither cognitive opportunities nor fair judicial authorities in order to provide justice today for 1915 events or the events before or after that date. The courts formed in the heat of the moment generally have more evidence; yet it is a historical truth that the courts are formed by the victorious sides and they can issue the decision they want. History is written by the victors. As long as the history, written by the victors, does not satisfy pure consciences, it causes gradual resistances.

Therefore, expecting history to reveal the naked facts sooner or later is in vain. If possible, history should be recorded in the heat of the moment and justice should be provided before it is late.

Justice delayed is not justice. History is by no means different from it. Confronting history and providing justice after the people who had some responsibilities in history passed away, means it evidently has some connections with today’s politics.

The ones who are seeking justice today showing their being oppressed as an excuse has become an alliance of the cruelest ones for justice. Thus, it illustrates that they are actually looking for revenge or power not justice. They are evidently no more than a resurrection of “the sorrows in the past” with the intention of demanding power and interest.

This confrontation neither will offer an advantage to the sufferers nor will it have a potential of imposing sanction on the torturers. And so, it is the field of Economy-Politics to understand who will benefit from this confrontation.

The genocide discourse is an economy-politics issue and it might be a breaking point of optimism towards Turkey’s increasing role. It can be seen as a warning for Turkey in order to give the impression that Turkey’s increasing role in foreign politics is problematic. This warning is certainly not a warning to dissuade Turkey from its route. However, this also illustrates that a powerful, active, and independent Turkey will not meet acclaims and cheers. Every year this issue is brought to the agenda and it is time for Turkey to adopt a new different attitude toward this issue. Let the USA approve the resolution because it is evident that it wants to hold Turkey hostage. It did until now, yet Turkey can end this and end considering it as a complex.

 


OTHER ARTICLES OF THE AUTHOR
A Social Sciences Congress That Witness the History: ATCOSS - 12 Nisan 2012 Perşembe 17:07
On the Way to Democratization: Education Reform and the Debate of “Religious Generation” - 02 Nisan 2012 Pazartesi 15:48
Ergenekon Cases and the Need for a New Agreement for New Turkey - 31 Ocak 2012 Salı 11:19
‘Arabian Spring’ with Its Past, Today and Future - 16 Ocak 2012 Pazartesi 09:41
Turkey Disburdened from Israel - 07 Eylül 2011 Çarşamba 18:09
Trial of Turkey and the World in Syria - 16 Ağustos 2011 Salı 14:15
Political Responsibility and New Constitution - 22 Haziran 2011 Çarşamba 12:11
Democratic Federalism or Feudalism? - 02 Haziran 2011 Perşembe 18:11
Commoditizing and Marketing the Kurdish Issue - 11 Mayıs 2011 Çarşamba 19:21
Coup Plotting is more Shameful than Rape - 29 Nisan 2011 Cuma 13:50
The Reports of the Workshops on the Alewite - 08 Nisan 2011 Cuma 17:38
Revolutions in the Middle East: The End or Evolution of Islamism? - 01 Nisan 2011 Cuma 13:26
The “Quite Instructive” Report of EP - 21 Mart 2011 Pazartesi 17:33
Transformation in Arab World: Has the Future Arrived - 17 Mart 2011 Perşembe 12:02
Kurdish People Doesn’t Deserve This Primitive Policy - 10 Mart 2011 Perşembe 15:24
Revolution: A Social Earthquake - 04 Mart 2011 Cuma 12:55
11 February Egyptian Revolution - 18 Şubat 2011 Cuma 09:57
The Subject of the Revolution and Islamist Politics - 12 Şubat 2011 Cumartesi 14:37
The President Mr.Gül’s Visit to Diyarbakır - 14 Ocak 2011 Cuma 16:22
The Arab-Turkish Conference of Social Sciences (ATCOSS) - 24 Aralık 2010 Cuma 16:18
Guide to Reading Conspiracy - 08 Aralık 2010 Çarşamba 15:39
Davutoğlu’s “Democratic NATO” Message - 10 Kasım 2010 Çarşamba 14:53
Turkey from China’s Perspective, China from Turkey’s Perspective - 05 Kasım 2010 Cuma 15:22
The Politicization of Alcohol - 01 Ekim 2010 Cuma 13:32
A Result which will Also Relieve “no” Voters - 17 Eylül 2010 Cuma 22:22
In Whose Pocket are Alevi People’s Votes? - 23 Ağustos 2010 Pazartesi 02:32
The Constitutional Amendment Consolidates the Rule of Law - 19 Ağustos 2010 Perşembe 17:33
Both Voting “NO” and wishing not to be “Pro-Coup” - 03 Ağustos 2010 Salı 16:38
Don’t the Ones Encouraging the Constitutional Court to Sin Have Fault? - 12 Temmuz 2010 Pazartesi 23:49
ESOF 2010 and Seeking Identity in European Science - 07 Temmuz 2010 Çarşamba 17:33
Totally Emotional Analysis - 02 Temmuz 2010 Cuma 13:45
Tutelage and Democracy - 29 Haziran 2010 Salı 17:16
“The Secret of Success” for the PKK - 28 Haziran 2010 Pazartesi 17:44
Whose Message is the PKK Carrying Again? - 22 Haziran 2010 Salı 13:36
A Shift in Turkish Foreign Policy? From the Policy of Self-Interest to the Policy of Virtue - 10 Haziran 2010 Perşembe 10:09
Ideology and the Council of State - 01 Mayıs 2010 Cumartesi 19:59
Have New Documents on 1915 Incidents Been Found? - 31 Mart 2010 Çarşamba 10:36
Genocide With One More Vote - 18 Mart 2010 Perşembe 14:48
The Economic and Political Aspects of the Genocide Discourse - 11 Mart 2010 Perşembe 14:49
Expecting Rationality from the Supporter of a Coup d’etat is “Insane” - 17 Şubat 2010 Çarşamba 11:56
Kandil Break for Democratic Initiative - 16 Aralık 2009 Çarşamba 00:36


IST will be holding a conference titled “Transatlantic Relations in the Framework of Actual Political Developments” at 10 am (10.00) on April 12th 2012.
09.04.2012 16:34:39

IST will be holding a conference titled "Global Financial Crisis and its Reflections on Turkey" at 3 pm (15:00) on February 10th, 2012 with the participation of Deputy Prime Minister Ali Babacan...
08.02.2012 17:34:41

SDE-Era Econometrics Seminar Series : "THE IMPACT OF OIL PRICE SHOCKS ON THE ECONOMIC GROWTH OF SELECTED MENA COUNTRIES
21.10.2011 13:55:20

SDE holds a panel on "International Arbitration Tribune and Turkey"
20.09.2011 13:57:47


<Mayıs 2012>
PtSaÇaPeCuCtPz
30123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031123
45678910

Do you favor Turkey's suspension of diplomatic relations with Israel?

Yes
No
No Idea


Content of this site is copyrighted to SDE. Except reasonable and partial quotation and exploitation under the Act No. 5846, Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works, via proper citation, may not be used or re-published without prior permission by SDE. Except for the institutional information on SDE, and the studies of SDE Academic Staff; all opinions and assessments expressed in this site reflect only the opinions of their authors and do not represent the institutional opinion of SDE.
Portal Design and Development: Omedya